Skip to content
Vidsly
← All guides
Channel Growth2 min read

YouTube Shorts vs Long-Form for a Faceless Channel: Which Should You Post?

Shorts find viewers fast; long-form earns watch time and mid-roll ads. How a faceless channel should split its output between 9:16 and 16:9, and what each format costs in scenes.


On this page6 sections
  1. 01What each format is for
  2. 02The format limits in Vidsly
  3. 03How to split your output by stage
  4. 04What each format costs in scenes
  5. 05The simple rule
  6. 06FAQ

What each format is for

  • Shorts (9:16) are discovery. They get shown to people who have never heard of you, they're fast to make, and they let you test a dozen hooks in the time one long video takes. Revenue per view is usually far lower than long-form.
  • Long-form (16:9) is where watch hours and ad revenue come from. Videos of 8 minutes or longer can carry mid-roll ads, and viewers who finish a long video are the ones most likely to subscribe and come back.

Neither is "better". They do different jobs, and most successful faceless channels use both.

The format limits in Vidsly

A Short can run up to 3 minutes and 34 scenes. A long-form video can run up to 10 minutes and 70 scenes. You can generate both from the same script, so one researched story can become a Short and a long video.

How to split your output by stage

  1. Before 1,000 subscribers: lead with Shorts. Post one most days, watch which topics and hooks hold viewers, and publish a long video every week or two on the topics that worked.
  2. Once a few Shorts take off: turn each winning topic into a long-form deep dive, and link the Short to it with YouTube's related-video link so Shorts viewers have somewhere to go next.
  3. Once long-form watch time builds: keep Shorts as the top of the funnel and put more effort into one strong long video a week.

What each format costs in scenes

A Short is typically 3 to 8 scenes. An 8-to-10-minute video is more like 40 to 70. On the unlimited lane, every clip costs zero credits within a daily allowance:

  • Creator (20 clips/day): several Shorts a day, or a 60-scene long video spread over 3 days.
  • Pro (40 clips/day): the same 60-scene video in 2 days.
  • Studio (60 clips/day): a 60-scene video inside one day's allowance.

When a video needs more than today's allowance, it renders what it can and continues after the midnight-UTC reset; it never fails halfway. HD clips on Unlimited Premiere (720p, Pro and Studio) count double against the same budget.

The simple rule

Shorts to find out what works, long-form to get paid for it. Read how to make YouTube Shorts with AI and how to make a 10-minute video with AI, then open the Studio.

4 questions

Frequently asked questions

Do Shorts make money?
Yes, through YouTube's Shorts revenue sharing once you're in the Partner Program, but revenue per view is usually much lower than long-form. Shorts are best treated as discovery that feeds your long videos.
How long does a video need to be for mid-roll ads?
YouTube allows mid-roll ads on videos 8 minutes or longer. Vidsly's long-form format runs up to 10 minutes and 70 scenes, enough room for an 8-minute video.
Can I make a Short and a long video from the same script?
Yes. Generate the script in 16:9 for the long video and in 9:16 for a Short, usually with a tighter cut of the script for the Short.
Should a new faceless channel post Shorts or long-form first?
Shorts first, for most niches. They're quick to make and show you which topics and hooks work. Then turn the topics that worked into long-form videos.
3 guides

Keep reading